top of page
Mediation Agency Logo_edited.png

How to Have Difficult Conversations in a Charity

Writer: Mediation Agency Team
Mediation Agency Team
12 minutes ago
7 min read

A practical guide for charity trustees and volunteer managers


Difficult Conversations - Charity Trustees and Volunteers


To have a difficult conversation in a charity, choose a private moment, explain what happened and why it matters, then ask how the other person saw it. Listen to their response and agree what needs to happen next.


If you’re reading this, you may already have someone in mind. A volunteer has missed two handovers, leaving someone else to cover at short notice, or a trustee keeps interrupting and quieter board members have stopped contributing. It’s understandable to hesitate when you value the person’s contribution and worry about how they’ll take it. This guide will help you prepare what to say. The ‘What to Do and What to Avoid’ checklist at the end gives you a quick reference to use before you speak.


1 - Decide who should have the difficult conversation in your charity

Start by working out what needs attention. A missed handover, an unclear role or a disagreement over how meetings are run may be suitable for an informal conversation. A safeguarding concern, a serious allegation or a formal complaint needs to be handled through the relevant procedure. If someone raises a safeguarding concern, pass it promptly to your designated safeguarding lead or use the reporting route in your policy. If a concern involves bullying, harassment or discrimination, check which procedure applies and who should assess it before trying to resolve it informally.


The right person to speak depends on the role and the issue. A volunteer manager will often handle an operational concern with a volunteer. A chair may be best placed to speak privately with a fellow trustee about their conduct at meetings. If the chair is involved in the dispute, check who can act fairly under your charity’s procedures. If you are a trustee concerned about a member of staff, check who has line management responsibility before approaching them. In a small charity, people often hold several roles, so be clear about which role you are acting in.


2 - Prepare what you need to say

Write down one or two examples. What did you see or hear yourself? What has someone else reported? What effect did it have on the people, the service or the board’s work? This helps you avoid opening with something broad like “People are unhappy with your attitude”, which gives the person little to respond to and can leave them wondering who has been talking about them.


Think about what you need from the meeting. You might want to understand why a handover was missed and agree how cover will be arranged next time. If you are speaking to a trustee, you might want to agree how they can challenge a proposal while giving colleagues time to finish. Check what was previously agreed and where there is room to adapt. If an expectation was unclear, be ready to acknowledge your part in that.


Give the person a private invitation with enough information to prepare. For example, “Could we have twenty minutes on Thursday to talk about how the last two Saturday handovers went and what would make them easier to manage?” Choose somewhere you can speak without being overheard. Check whether a different time, format or venue would make it easier for them to take part.


3 - Open with what happened and why it matters

Start calmly and name the issue early. You can recognise what the person contributes and still be direct about what needs attention. A volunteer manager might say:

“On the last two Saturdays, we didn’t have a handover before the drop-in closed. The next volunteers had to work out which calls still needed a response, and one had to stay late to catch up. Can you talk me through what happened from your side?”

For a trustee, the opening might sound like this:

“At Monday’s meeting, you spoke while Priya was explaining her concerns about the budget, and we moved to a vote before she finished. I’m concerned we made a decision before hearing everything we needed to. How did you see it?”

If you are raising something reported to you, say so and share only the details you can fairly disclose. Avoid guessing at the other person’s intentions. They may remember the same event differently, and you can still explain why it needs discussing.


4 - Listen for what could change

Give the person time to answer, even if there is a pause. You might learn that the volunteer thought a message in the rota group counted as a handover, or that the trustee believed the chair had already called time on the discussion. Ask a question that helps you understand what they were working with. “What did you understand the arrangement to be?” often gets a fuller answer than “Why didn’t you follow it?”


Check what you’ve heard before moving to solutions. “It sounds as though you thought someone else was picking up the calls. Have I got that right?” If they raise a concern about your own role, give it space. A volunteer might tell you they flagged a clash weeks ago and heard nothing back. You can take responsibility for missing that message and still agree how the next shift will be covered.


If they become upset, offer a pause. If the discussion turns personal, bring it back to the issue or agree a time to resume. If they disclose something that needs to be referred under a policy, explain what you need to do next and who may need to know. Promise only the privacy you can provide.


5 - Agree a next step you can both describe

An encouraging conversation can still leave people with different ideas about what they agreed. Before you finish, check who will do what, when they will do it and what support they need. Invite the person to say what might get in the way while you still have time to adjust the plan.


For the handover, the manager could agree to share a short checklist by Friday. The volunteer could agree to complete it in the designated place before leaving each shift and contact the duty lead if they need to leave early. You might review the arrangement after two weekends. For the board, the chair might agree to invite each trustee to speak before a vote and intervene if someone is interrupted. The trustee might agree to make a note of their point and come back to it when invited. The chair and trustee can check in after the next meeting.


If you disagree about what happened, see whether you can still agree how to handle the next shift or meeting. If agreement is out of reach, explain what remains open and when you will come back to them. Where a decision is needed, be clear about who is responsible for making it.


Before you wrap up, give the other person a chance to check your summary. You could say, “I’ll send you the checklist on Friday and we’ll try it for the next two weekends. Is that what you understood too?” If someone says yes very quickly or seems hesitant, give them time to think. In a charity, the person who allocates shifts or chairs the board can have more influence than they realise. A simple “What would make that difficult?” gives the other person room to raise a practical objection.


6 - Follow up and decide whether more support is needed

Keep a brief, factual record in line with your charity’s procedures. An informal follow-up can confirm the actions, who owns them and the review date. Keep sensitive details within the appropriate record and only share information with people who need it. At the review, ask what has improved and whether anything still makes the agreement difficult to keep. If the problem continues, check whether the arrangement needs adjusting or whether it is time to use the relevant procedure.


Sometimes the relationship itself has become difficult, or everyone close to the issue has already taken a position. Where it is appropriate and the people involved are willing to take part, an independent facilitator or mediator can help them explain what has happened and agree ways to work together. If a matter requires a formal response, follow that process and consider whether relationship support could help at a suitable stage.


If you are a member of Basingstoke Voluntary Action and are unsure how to approach a difficult conversation, the Mediation Agency’s Early Resolution Service offers free initial support. You can talk through what is happening, consider your options and find out whether a facilitated conversation might help. If you are not part of Basingstoke Voluntary Action, you can still find out more about our Early Resolution Services and talk to the team about how we can help.


Further support


Difficult Conversations Checklist

Use this before you speak to a colleague and again before you end the conversation.


What to Do

  • Check who should lead the conversation and whether a safeguarding, complaints or other procedure applies.

  • Choose a private setting and give the person enough notice to prepare.

  • Name one or two specific examples and explain the effect on colleagues, volunteers or the service.

  • Ask how they saw it, give them time to answer and check you’ve understood.

  • Agree who will do what, by when, and what support is needed.

  • Make a brief factual note in line with your charity’s procedures and set a date to review what’s changed.


What to Avoid

  • Raising the issue in a board meeting, group chat or corridor where others can hear.

  • Using labels such as “unreliable” or speaking for others with phrases like “everyone thinks”.

  • Presenting second-hand accounts as facts or assuming you know why someone acted as they did.

  • Interrupting to defend yourself or pressing for agreement when someone needs time to think.

  • Promising to keep everything between you, especially where a concern may need to be reported.

  • Trying to settle a safeguarding concern informally or letting the conversation end with a vague “let’s do better”.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page